SKIP TO CONTENT
6 Common Mistakes When Filing Wildfire Smoke Damage Claims
In the wake of the devastating Palisades Fires, many homeowners are still grappling with the challenges of rebuilding their lives and properties. The path to recovery is fraught with obstacles, from navigating complex insurance claims to dealing with the emotional toll of loss.
At Rubin Adjusting, we’ve witnessed firsthand how easily homeowners can stumble into mistakes that jeopardize their path to fair compensation. Insurers often look for any reason to minimize or deny claims, making it crucial to avoid common pitfalls.
Drawing on our experience and recent legal developments, including a landmark court ruling that smoke damage is property damage, we want to highlight these critical errors to help you protect your rights.
1. Delaying Your Claim
While it might seem logical to wait until the immediate crisis subsides, procrastination can be a critical mistake. Smoke damage doesn’t improve with time; in fact, it often worsens. Residues can become more difficult to remove, and the window for filing a claim under most insurance policies has strict deadlines.
Submitting a rushed or incomplete claim due to delay can also trigger unnecessary back-and-forth with your insurer. This can further slow down the entire process and potentially lead to reduced settlements or outright denials due to “insufficient evidence” or “lack of documentation.”
2. Underestimating the Scope of Smoke and Ash Damage
One of the most frequent errors we observe is a superficial assessment of property damage. Homeowners often focus on visible soot and ash, failing to recognize the insidious reach of wildfire smoke.
These microscopic particles can infiltrate HVAC systems, permeate walls and insulation, and embed themselves in furniture and belongings. Without a meticulous and thorough inspection, much of this hidden damage goes unnoticed and, consequently, unclaimed. Remember, not all smoke damage is visible; subtle yet significant impacts on air quality must also be considered.
3. Inadequate Documentation
A successful claim hinges on robust documentation. This goes beyond a few quick snapshots of the damage. It requires high-quality images and videos capturing all affected areas, detailed written descriptions of the damage, and, when necessary, reports from environmental specialists to assess air quality and unseen contamination.
This also includes meticulously documenting all communication with your insurer – every call, email, and reference number. This paper trail becomes invaluable if delays or disputes arise.
4. Misunderstanding Your Policy
Many homeowners make the critical mistake of not fully understanding their insurance policy before filing a claim. Smoke and ash coverage can vary significantly, with exclusions or limits that can lead to unwelcome surprises.
It’s vital to understand the specifics of your policy, including any special provisions for smoke damage or coverage for additional living expenses if your property becomes uninhabitable. Taking the time to review your policy or consulting with a public insurance adjuster upfront can be the difference between a successful claim and a significant financial burden.
5. Undervaluing Your Losses
Estimating the cost of smoke damage is complicated.
How do you value items that weren’t burned but were contaminated?
What qualifies as a repair versus a replacement?
Creating a personal property inventory—a complete list of damaged items with details like age, condition, and estimated value—is a great place to start. If you’re unsure how to begin, check out our guide: How to Prepare a Personal Property Inventory.
6. Going at it Alone
Filing a smoke damage claim isn’t just a logistical challenge—it’s an emotional one. Wildfires displace families, destroy memories, and leave a lasting mental toll. Trying to manage a complicated insurance process while also coping with loss can be overwhelming.
It’s okay to ask for help. Support groups, community resources, and professional advocates can make all the difference.
The Power of Precedent: A Recent Victory for Smoke Damage Claims
A recent legal victory underscores the importance of recognizing the tangible nature of smoke damage. On January 10, 2025, U.S. District Judge Jacqueline Scott Corley made a landmark ruling stating that “smoke, soot, ash, char and its chemical byproducts absolutely are property damage.”
This decision is particularly significant for businesses impacted by events like the recent LA County wildfires, as it legally solidifies smoke-related contamination as physical damage eligible for coverage under all-risk insurance policies. But it’s important for homeowners to be aware of too as this recognition can make it more difficult for insurers to deny or minimize claims based on arguments that smoke contamination isn’t tangible property damage.
How Working With a Public Insurance Adjuster Can Help
Navigating the complexities of a smoke damage claim doesn’t have to be an overwhelming experience. At Rubin Adjusting, we recognize the complexities of claims and remain updated on important legal developments, such as the recent ruling by U.S. District Judge Jacqueline Scott Corley.
No matter what stage you are in the claim filing process, our team is here to assist you. When you partner with Rubin Adjusting, you’re choosing a team that knows how to advocate for you, every step of the way.